Towards standardized whole exome sequencing (WES) for cancer patients: lessons from a multicentric pilot study

A growing number of druggable targets and national initiatives for precision oncology necessitate broader genomic profiling for many cancer patients. Whole exome sequencing (WES) offers unbiased analysis of the entire coding sequence, segmentation-based detection of copy number alterations (CNAs), and accurate determination of complex biomarkers including tumor mutational burden (TMB), homologous recombination repair deficiency (HRD), and microsatellite instability (MSI). To assess the inter-institution variability of clinical WES, we performed a comparative pilot study between German Centers of Personalized Medicine (ZPMs) from five participating institutions. Tumor and matched normal DNA from 30 patients were analyzed using custom sequencing protocols and bioinformatic pipelines. Calling of somatic variants was highly concordant with a sensitivity between 91-95% and a positive predictive value (PPV) of 82-95% compared with a three-institution consensus and full agreement for 16 of 17 druggable targets. Deviations were observed for cases with low VAF or coverage, differing annotations, and different filter protocols. CNAs showed overall agreement in 76% for the genomic sequence with high wet-lab variability. Complex biomarkers correlated strongly between institutions (HRD: 0.79-1, TMB: 0.97-0.99) and all institutions agreed on microsatellite instability. This study will contribute to the development of quality control frameworks for comprehensive genomic profiling and sheds light onto parameters that require stringent standardization.

Type: Other
Archiver: European Genome-Phenome Archive (EGA)

1 Dataset 1 Publication

Click on a Dataset ID in the table below to learn more, and to find out who to contact about access to these data

Dataset ID	Description	Technology	Samples
EGAD00001011087	ZPM WES Pilot consisting of 30 samples paired tumor/normal analyzed with WES at four different laboratories in Germany.	Illumina NovaSeq 6000 unspecified	30

Publications	Citations
Multicentric pilot study to standardize clinical whole exome sequencing (WES) for cancer patients. Menzel M, Ossowski S, Kral S, Metzger P, Horak P, Marienfeld R, Boerries M, Wolter S, Ball M, Neumann O, Armeanu-Ebinger S, Schroeder C, Matysiak U, Goldschmid H, Schipperges V, Fürstberger A, Allgäuer M, Eberhardt T, Niewöhner J, Blaumeiser A, Ploeger C, Haack TB, Tay TKY, Kelemen O, Pauli T, Kirchner M, Kluck K, Ott A, Renner M, Admard J, Gschwind A, Lassmann S, Kestler H, Fend F, Illert AL, Werner M, Möller P, Seufferlein TTW, Malek N, Schirmacher P, Fröhling S, Kazdal D, Budczies J, Stenzinger A. NPJ Precis Oncol 7: 2023 106	2

Publications

Citations

Multicentric pilot study to standardize clinical whole exome sequencing (WES) for cancer patients.
Menzel M, Ossowski S, Kral S, Metzger P, Horak P, Marienfeld R, Boerries M, Wolter S, Ball M, Neumann O, Armeanu-Ebinger S, Schroeder C, Matysiak U, Goldschmid H, Schipperges V, Fürstberger A, Allgäuer M, Eberhardt T, Niewöhner J, Blaumeiser A, Ploeger C, Haack TB, Tay TKY, Kelemen O, Pauli T, Kirchner M, Kluck K, Ott A, Renner M, Admard J, Gschwind A, Lassmann S, Kestler H, Fend F, Illert AL, Werner M, Möller P, Seufferlein TTW, Malek N, Schirmacher P, Fröhling S, Kazdal D, Budczies J, Stenzinger A. NPJ Precis Oncol 7: 2023 106